Cincinnati Public Schools: one referendum question
Issue 4 · New operating levy
An additional tax for the benefit of the Cincinnati City School District for the purpose of current expenses that the county auditor estimates will collect $66,336,723 annually, at a rate not exceeding 7 mills for each $1 of taxable value, which amounts to $245 for each $100,000 of the county auditor's market value, for 5 years, commencing in 2026, first due in calendar year 2027. The county auditor has certified that the amount by which the carry-over balance in the district's general operating budget from the preceding fiscal year exceeds the district's general fund expenditures made in the preceding fiscal year is $37,352,861, which is 6% of those expenditures.
33,458 students in 2025-26, down from a peak of 36,674 in 2019-20; −5.1% over five years against +8.3% for the regional peer median (within 50 miles).
Achievement
Performance index 71.0 of 120 in 2025-26 (Ohio median 88.3); 3.0 stars overall; four-year graduation 80.6%.
Spending
$21,511 per pupil in operating spending (2024-25), above the peer median of $20,666; the state supplies 26% of revenue and local taxes 50%.
Reserves
$43.01 million in general-fund cash at the end of FY2026; the unreserved balance was 4.7% of spending (Ohio median 36.2%).
Property taxes
38.07 effective residential mills for current expenses in 2026 (Ohio median 24.39).
Students
91% economically disadvantaged, 11% English learners, 21.6% with disabilities (2024-25).
The story
What is happening now
Three budget cycles of cuts. CPS closed gaps of about $104M (FY2025), $52M (FY2026) and $59M (FY2027) by cutting roughly 550 positions, ending IB programs at three schools and imposing five unpaid furlough days; the FY2027 budget ($634.6M) is smaller than FY2025’s.
Fiscal caution. On September 2, 2026 the state placed CPS in fiscal caution over a projected $44.5M deficit in FY2029; a corrective plan is due November 30, and the district says about $44M of cuts must be planned even if the levy passes.
Issue 4. A new 7-mill, five-year operating levy: $66.3M a year, $245 per $100,000 of home value, CPS’s first new operating ask since 2016. The board first chose a 0.75% earned-income tax (5–2), then rescinded it a week later (6–1) after both county parties objected.
A formula that treats Cincinnati as rich. Its large commercial and utility tax base means the state pays only about 27.5% of its formula base cost, against 57–77% for most big-city districts. The 2025–26 property-tax laws cost CPS about $10.9M a year and limit renewals of its three emergency levies ($165M, 26% of revenue) to five years.
Choice. Of students living in the district in 2025-26, 30,155 attended CPS, 8,431 used EdChoice vouchers and 6,176 attended charter schools; CPS spends about $50M a year on transportation, including for private and charter students.
Results improving from a low base. 3 stars on the 2025-26 report card (first time meeting standards) and the highest performance index of the eight big urban districts — but graduation fell to 80.6% for the class of 2025 and chronic absence was 45.6%.
What to watch
November 3: Issue 4 (and Dayton’s 7-mill request, the other big-city levy).
November 30: the fiscal-caution corrective plan, and any list of school closures or consolidations.
The next teachers’ contract: the forecast assumes 0.35% salary growth a year.
2029–30: renewal of the $65M emergency levy, now limited to five years; the EdChoice appeal, in which CPS is a plaintiff.
Students and community
Students served
Cincinnati enrolled 33,458 students in 2025-26. Enrollment peaked at 36,674 in 2019-20. Since 2006-07 it has changed −1.2%, against −19.2% for the regional peer median (within 50 miles) and −19.5% for the median Ohio district.
Districts that serve free meals to every student report every student as economically disadvantaged. For the 123 Ohio districts where that raised the share by 25 points or more to 95% or above in one year, this briefing uses the district’s last share before the rise.
Where resident students go
Since 2021-22 the state pays community schools, EdChoice private schools and open-enrollment districts directly, so these students no longer appear as deductions in Cincinnati’s budget, but the district still receives no state aid for them and, for most private and charter students in grades K–8, must provide or pay for transportation.
Measure
Cincinnati
Regional peers (median)
Ohio (median)
Percentile
Year
Resident students in district schools
30,155
11,204
1,180
100th
2025-26
Resident students on EdChoice
8,431
3,008
61
100th
2025-26
Resident students in community (charter) schools
6,176
6,651
39
99th
2025-26
Resident students open-enrolled elsewhere
657
1,195
97
98th
2025-26
Community
Measure
Cincinnati
Regional peers (median)
Ohio (median)
Percentile
Year
Median household income
$54,325
$44,543
$73,778
12th
2020–24 ACS
Poverty rate
24.4%
27.4%
9.9%
94th
2020–24 ACS
Adults with a bachelor's degree
41.8%
20.6%
21.9%
87th
2020–24 ACS
Median home value
$224,600
$96,900
$196,400
67th
2020–24 ACS
Home values against nearby districts
Across the five most recent Census releases (2016–20 to 2020–24), the median owner-occupied home in Cincinnati averaged $184,260, 126% above the median of the 1 districts within 50 miles ($81,480). That ranks highest of 2 in the area and at the 64th percentile of Ohio districts (state median $167,900).
ACS 5-year release
Cincinnati
Nearby median
Difference
Ohio median
2016–20
$145,900
$67,400
+116%
$142,600
2017–21
$158,300
$70,700
+124%
$149,100
2018–22
$184,700
$82,700
+123%
$167,700
2019–23
$207,800
$89,700
+132%
$182,500
2020–24
$224,600
$96,900
+132%
$196,400
Five-release average
$184,260
$81,480
+126%
$167,900
U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey 5-year estimates, median value of owner-occupied homes (table B25077), in nominal dollars. Consecutive releases share four of their five survey years, so the average is a smoothed level rather than five independent years. Nearby districts are those whose NCES office address lies within 50 miles of Cincinnati's: Dayton (46 mi, $81,480).
Ohio Department of Education and Workforce Report Card and District Profile (Cupp) Report; U.S. Census ACS 5-year. Student characteristics compare with the peers; enrollment, school choice and community figures with the regional peers (within 50 miles): Dayton.
Achievement
Performance index and graduation
Cincinnati’s performance index — a weighted average of state test results on a 0–120 scale — was 71.0 in 2025-26, against 64.5 for the peer median and 88.3 for the median Ohio district (7th percentile).
CincinnatiPeers (median)Ohio districts (median)
Measure
Cincinnati
Peer medianregional beneath
Ohio (median)
Percentile
Year
Performance index (of 120)
71.0
64.5regional 55.4
88.3
7th
2025-26
Performance index, % of maximum
64.4%
58.5%regional 50.3%
80.1%
7th
2025-26
Math proficient
40.2%
31.5%regional 20.2%
63.5%
9th
2025-26
Four-year graduation rate
80.6%
88.8%regional 66.7%
97.2%
1st
Class of 2025
Chronically absent
44.6%
35.0%regional 43.8%
16.4%
98th
2025-26
Overall rating (stars)
3.0
2.8regional 2.0
4.0
15th
2025-26
CincinnatiPeers (median)Ohio districts (median)
Ohio Department of Education and Workforce Report Card. No state tests in 2019-20; star ratings began in 2022-23.
Finances
Spending, revenue and reserves
Cincinnati spent $21,511 per pupil on operations in 2024-25, against $20,666 for the peer median and $16,580 for the median Ohio district. Ohio’s formula assumes each district can raise a local share based on its property values and residents’ incomes; the state supplied 26% of Cincinnati’s revenue. At the end of FY2026 the district held $43.01 million in general-fund cash, an unreserved balance of 4.7% of a year’s spending.
CincinnatiPeers (median)Ohio districts (median)
CincinnatiPeers (median)Ohio districts (median)
Measure
Cincinnati
Peer medianregional beneath
Ohio (median)
Percentile
Year
Operating spending per pupil
$21,511
$20,666regional $22,858
$16,580
91st
2024-25
Revenue per pupil
$21,348
$20,403regional $22,414
$18,150
83rd
2024-25
State share of revenue
26%
47%regional 51%
43%
19th
2024-25
Local share of revenue
50%
34%regional 26%
42%
69th
2024-25
Federal share of revenue
16%
15%regional 18%
6%
94th
2024-25
General-fund cash, end of year
$43.01 million
$78.48 millionregional $114.13 million
$8.3 million
95th
FY2026
Unreserved balance, % of spending
4.7%
28.0%regional 35.4%
36.2%
2nd
FY2026
Average teacher salary
$84,019
$81,927regional $69,101
$69,163
89th
2024-25
Property value per pupil
$293,004
$208,960regional $167,244
$267,197
58th
2023-24
ODEW District Profile (Cupp) Report; five-year forecast actuals (general operating funds, cash basis) as filed with ODEW.
Levies and property taxes
Millage and the levy record
Ohio’s H.B. 920 reduction factors cut the effective rate of voted levies as property values rise, so most levies raise a fixed number of dollars and districts must return to voters to keep pace; no district’s effective current-expense rate can fall below 20 mills. Cincinnati’s effective residential rate was 38.07 mills (Ohio median 24.39). Since January 2026, districts can no longer place new emergency, substitute or replacement levies on the ballot.
Measure
Cincinnati
Regional peers (median)
Ohio (median)
Percentile
Year
Effective residential millage, current expenses
38.07
29.21
24.39
95th
Tax year 2025
Effective business millage, current expenses
45.41
57.35
26.58
90th
2024-25
Total voted operating millage
63.79
67.55
41.87
82nd
2024-25
Median property tax on owner-occupied homes
$3,146
$1,608
$2,228
77th
2020–24 ACS
As a share of household income
5.8%
3.6%
3.1%
96th
2020–24 ACS
Past school tax issues
Cincinnati has put 6 school tax issues to voters since 2016; all passed. Statewide, the Ohio School Boards Association records 2,342 school tax issues from 2016 through May 2026; 66% passed, and 39% of new-money issues.
Election
Issue
Result
Yes vote
Nov 2025
Emergency (renewal), 5.05 mills
Passed
72.89%
Nov 2022
Emergency (renewal), 6.8 mills
Passed
67.51%
Nov 2020
Emergency (renewal), 7.34 mills
Passed
73.6%
Nov 2019
Emergency (renewal), 10.06 mills
Passed
73.26%
Nov 2017
Emergency (renewal), 8.43 mills
Passed
66.68%
Nov 2016
Emergency (new), 7.93 mills
Passed
62.27%
Ohio School Boards Association school election results (unofficial), 2016–2026.
Ohio Department of Taxation and ODEW District Profile Report (effective millage); U.S. Census ACS 5-year; Ohio School Boards Association election results.
Claims check
What the record shows
Claims from the district, its supporters and critics, checked against state data, the district’s forecasts and audits, and rating-agency reports.
Claim
Who
The record
Verdict
Issue 4 costs $245 per $100,000
CPS, campaign
Ballot text: $245; $66.3M a year
Confirmed
Without the levy, an $89M cash deficit by FY2030
CPS
Forecast says so; but the Nov. 2022 forecast’s −$150M for June 2026 became +$43M
Confirmed as forecast; record overstates
CPS “cut $100 million over the last three years”
YES for CPS
Cuts are against projected spending; actual spending $604M (FY2024) → $645M → $635M budget
Partly
Spends less per student than every other big urban district
YES for CPS
ODEW operating spending: CPS $21,511, second-lowest of the eight after Akron ($21,165)
Partly
Highest performance index of the urban eight
Superintendent
CPS 71.0; others 55.4–64.8
Confirmed
“Thirty years” of state cuts; “30% less state funding”
Campaign; board president
Aid −7.2% FY2024–26; the FY2022 drop was the direct-payment accounting change
Partly / contradicted
A failed levy risks a “state takeover”
Fox19 framing; treasurer
Caution is step one of three; a commission needs fiscal emergency; $43M cash today
Partly
Finances are solid; reserves 25–35% of revenue
Moody’s, Fitch
GAAP general fund $169.1M; Aa2 / AA — versus $43M cash on the state’s basis
Confirmed (different basis)
No specific plan for spending the levy
Board VP; parent network
Levy page lists five broad categories; no allocation
Confirmed
Sources: the district’s five-year forecasts, board resolutions and audited financial statements; Ohio Department of Education and Workforce and Department of Taxation data; county boards of elections; rating-agency reports; local news coverage.
Comparison districts
Who this briefing compares the district with
Wherever this briefing sets Cincinnati beside other districts, it uses the groups below. A group figure is the middle value across its members, each counted equally, so one large member cannot dominate it.
Peers 12 districts
The 12 Ohio districts (city, local and exempted-village districts) most like Cincinnati on four equally weighted factors: total enrollment (compared as a ratio), operating spending per pupil, students per teacher and the share of economically disadvantaged students, each difference scaled by how much the factor varies across districts, and none more than two standard deviations away on any one. The group starts with nearby districts that match closely (within half a standard deviation on average) and fills the rest from anywhere in the state. Peers carry the achievement, spending and staffing comparisons.
District
County
Miles
Enrollment
Operating spending per pupil
Students per teacher
Econ. disadvantaged
Kettering
Montgomery
43
7,492
$18,527
16.5
50.7%
Dayton
Montgomery
46
12,790
$22,858
17.1
98.9%
Springfield City
Clark
66
6,962
$20,167
14.0
100.0%
South-Western
Franklin
93
22,037
$16,173
17.7
66.7%
Columbus
Franklin
99
45,083
$25,649
15.5
100.0%
Reynoldsburg
Franklin
107
6,710
$16,031
16.9
71.6%
Westerville
Franklin
108
14,151
$17,495
17.1
42.3%
Toledo
Lucas
182
20,506
$22,175
15.2
98.9%
Canton City
Stark
202
7,214
$22,305
15.1
100.0%
Akron
Summit
208
19,126
$21,165
13.2
100.0%
Parma
Cuyahoga
212
8,802
$19,373
18.3
60.2%
Cleveland
Cuyahoga
221
31,676
$25,694
16.7
100.0%
Regional peers 1 districts
The 1 districts (city, local and exempted-village districts) within 50 miles of Cincinnati, straight line between district offices, whose profile on the same four factors is comparable: on average within one standard deviation. Fewer than five comparable districts lie within 25 miles, and only 1 within 50, so the group is smaller than usual. They carry enrollment, property taxes and home values, and their median sits beneath the peer median elsewhere. A district in both groups appears in both lists.
District
County
Miles
Enrollment
Operating spending per pupil
Students per teacher
Econ. disadvantaged
Dayton
Montgomery
46
12,790
$22,858
17.1
98.9%
“Ohio median” is the middle value across Ohio’s city, local and exempted-village school districts; career centers and community schools are left out.